Famed investor Peter Schiff has landed in hot water after he listed “married women entering the workforce” as a cause of today’s housing crisis.
The financial commentator shared his controversial take in a post on X (formerly Twitter) on August 6 — starting with an observation on mortgage rates: “The 30-year, fixed-rate #mortgage peaked at 18.45% in Oct. 1981 and troughed at 2.65% in 2021. The current rate is 7.4% and rising.”
Schiff went on to write: “40 years of falling mortgage rates, plus married women entering the workforce, allowed home prices to rise much faster than incomes.”
This comment went down like a lead balloon with some X users, with one simply responding: “Of course it’s the women’s fault. Nice peter.”
Another wrote: “You just insulted every woman who fought tooth and nail to break the glass ceiling, compete in the workplace, further civilization’s progressive certainty, I can’t think of a single woman that’s gonna roll with your 1947 take on the female workforce.”
Schiff clapped back, saying: “That’s not what I meant.” Here’s what he says he really meant.
What did Schiff really mean?
Schiff set up his contentious post by pointing out that mortgage rates hit a record 18.45% in 1981. What caused that monumental number in the eighties?
The Federal Reserve hiked the federal funds rate to 21% in June 1981, in reaction to rising oil prices, government overspending and an uptick in wages. When inflation is high, the value of the dollar decreases and lenders typically charge a higher rate of interest to compensate. This means everything — including housing — is more expensive.
“Married women worked to help their husbands buy more expensive homes,” Schiff explained. “Women working didn’t cause home prices to rise, but rising home prices caused women to get jobs. It was inflation that caused home prices to rise.”
The extreme inflation in the late 1970s and early 1980s spurred far more women to enter the workforce — with the help of new training and job development programs under the 1973 Comprehensive Employment and Training Act (CETA) as well as favorable developments like employer-sponsored day care and paid family leave .
“‘Married women entering the workforce’ wasn’t a cause of inflation, it was an effect of inflation,” one X user reacted in a reply to Schiff’s post. “It became a necessity in the 70’s. Of course there were other reasons, but inflation was one of them.”
Schiff replied in a thread: “Correct, plus rising taxes. Taxes and inflation reduced real earning of married men. So their wives were forced to get jobs to make up for that loss.”
Read more: How can I stop the pain and make money in this nightmarish market? Here’s 1 simple way you can protect your nest egg
Soaring housing costs
One metric used to gauge housing affordability is the “home price to median household income ratio.” At the beginning of the 1980s, the ratio stood at 4.69, compared to 7.69 as of April 30, 2023.
That means the average single-family house in the U.S. today costs more than seven times the median annual household income.
So what’s causing the current affordability crisis?
Home prices surged during the pandemic, when record-low mortgage rates, accommodative monetary policy and new remote working trends caused the demand for homes to spike. At the same time, the supply of new housing dropped due to pandemic-related disruptions to supply chains and industry labor pools.
Now, mortgage rates are ticking up again and home prices keep rising because there are so few homes for sale — meaning there’s more competition for the ones that are on the market.
Beyond that, other costs liked home maintenance, home insurance and property taxes have also spiked — and Schiff thinks these trends will “likely accelerate over the next few years” until inflation and interest rates have cooled down.
What to read next
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.